Several major European NGOs join landmark EtCA legal case

Several major European NGOs will today (27th June) ask the European Court of Justice to allow them to join the landmark End the Cage Age (EtCA) legal action against the European Commission.

The NGOs – which include The ECI Campaign, Eurogroup for Animals, foodwatch International and Animal Equality – will ask to become interveners in the action arguing that they are directly impacted by the Commission’s failure to deliver its promise to ban caged animal farming.

If accepted by the Court as an intervener, each NGO will present arguments showing how the Commission’s failure to deliver legislative proposals for a cage ban by the end of 2023 has a direct impact on their interests.

EU must uphold legally-binding commitment

In 2021, the Commission made a legally-binding commitment to introduce legislative proposals for an EU ban on caged farming before the end of 2023. This followed the successful EtCA ECI campaign, led by Compassion and supported by 170 European NGOs from across the EU, and which secured the signatures of more than 1.4 million EU citizens.

Launched by the Citizens’ Committee of the EtCA ECI in March, this legal case, which we are funding, is the first to hold the Commission to account over its failure to act on an ECI that it has committed to deliver. If successful, the Commission would be compelled by the Court to establish a clear and reasonable timescale to bring forward the legislative proposals, and to grant access to its file on the EtCA ECI.

Annamaria Pisapia, Head of Compassion in World Farming Italy and spokesperson for the Citizens’ Committee of the EtCA ECI, said: “The European Commission must deliver on its legally binding commitment to ban caged animal farming. Its failure to do so not only impacts around 300 million farmed animals suffering every year in cages, it damages our environment and makes a mockery of the ECI as a democratic tool for EU citizens, especially for the 1.4 million who signed it.
“We are thrilled these NGOs are backing the End the Cage Age legal action to hold the European Commission to account. It shows how a cage ban matters from so many points of view. We will not rest until the Commission delivers on its promise and every cage is an empty cage.”

EU citizens overwhelmingly back cage ban

An overwhelming 89% of EU citizens* believe animals should not be farmed in individual cages and the European Food Safety Authority has backed the phasing out of cages on welfare grounds for pigs, dairy calves, laying hens, ducks, quail and rabbits.

Across the EU, around 300 million pigs, hens, rabbits, ducks, quail and geese spend most of their lives in cages every year. Laying hens and rabbits are confined to barren cages about the size of an A4 sheet of paper. Sows are forced to nurse their piglets in crates so small they can’t even turn around. Ducks and geese are caged for force-feeding to produce foie gras.

Carsten Berg, Director of The ECI Campaign, said: “It's not only the fate of animals that hangs in the balance here, it's also the fate of the ECI, and with it, the fate of EU democracy. Never before has an EU participation instrument resulted in significant EU policy change. The Commission's promise in response to this ECI was unique in that respect. It's highly regrettable that it seems to require intervention by the Court to hold the Commission to its own promise, but if that is what it takes, we are here for it."

Jörg Rohwedder, Executive Director of foodwatch International, said: “The suffering of millions of farmed animals makes the failure of EU agricultural policy very clear. foodwatch has actively supported the End the Cage Age ECI from the very beginning – as a watchdog organisation, we are not giving up until the very end. Ignoring 1.4 million European consumers calling for a ban on cages and not sticking to the promised timeline is unacceptable. Consumers don’t want to buy products from caged animals! ECI’s like this are important tools to ensure a participatory process and make sure that consumers are heard. We won’t let it go.”

Reineke Hameleers, CEO of Eurogroup for Animals, said: “EU citizens have made use of the democratic tool at their disposal - they want these millions of animals out of cages. There is no argument against ending animal suffering. Yet with the Commission’s silence on the issue, we do question the very democratic purpose of the ECI.”

Supporters are being urged to back the legal action by sharing posts about the case on social media and tagging the European Commission (@EU_Commission).